Twigs Trail

Twig Red Head shotTwigs Trail of Dirty Tricks –  By The Numbers

1 & 2 –  Hijacking my Pen Name Twice While Sending Out the Last Two Emails on Renewing Chautauqua’s Leadership and Suggesting a Taxing Alternative to Fund the New Amp.

3 – Posting Dozens of Negative Comments On My Site Impersonating Many Chautauquans and Threatening Others. Some of the comments were actual emails sent by people who thought they were replying directly to me. Twig received them and used them to post on my site and added/changed the content to suit his purposes. I have confirmed that with a few people impersonated.

What follows are the vast majority (35) of the comments that were posted to my Drift of the Day site between Monday 11/23 – Thursday 12/3 in response to me disclaiming the emails sent out by Twig using my pen name. None of my other posts have received more than  a dozen comments. So when the comments started rolling in fast and furious on Black Friday I was more than a little concerned as some of them were mean spirited attacks on me in general and more specifically on my use of a pen name. But  as the carpet bombing continued they started calling out, and threatening other Chautauquans to try to smoke me out. I dug a little deeper and found out that ONE IP (Internet Protocol) address was responsible for 30 of the negative comments, as Twig was impersonating a whole bunch of Chautauquans to post on my site. I approved many of these despite an overall feeling of dread and helplessness as I didn’t want to be accused of censoring anyone. Once I realized what was going on I pulled all of them, and my defending replies, from my site. A little internet sleuthing later, and with a little help from some friends, I had figured out that Twig was responsible for the fake George emails, and all but two of the negative comments. Below are the results from the IP search.

An Internet Protocol address (IP address) is a numerical label assigned to each device (e.g., computer, printer) participating in a   computer network  that uses the Internet Protocol for communication. An IP address serves two principal functions: host or network interface identification and location addressing.

Internet Protocol (IP) Address:   99.114.148.53

Location:   United States, North Carolina, Charlotte

Latitude & Longitude:   35.227090, -80.843130 (35°13’38″N   80°50’35″W)

ISP (Internet Service Provider):   SBC Global Services, Inc., doing business as AT&T Global Services

Net Speed:   (DSL) Broadband/Cable/Fiber

IDD & Area Code:   (1) 704

ZIP Code:   28201

Mobile Network Code (MNC)    030/150/170/410/560/680

Usage Type        (ISP) Fixed Line ISP, (MOB) Mobile ISP

Anonymous Proxy           No

Twig's IP Map

William (Twig) Branch – IP Address 99.114.148.53 Info & Map –  Charlotte,  NC

Please note his IP address and internet service provider under most of  comments below: 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

Each comment that  was posted to my site is numbered below.  My commentary on each comment is first in bold above each comment posted on my Not Me disclaimer:

1 – I’m not sure if this is the real Hale Oliver with the first post on my Not Me disclaimer, as it’s not Twigs IP address. It is however, located at University of North Carolina – Charlotte, and too close to Twig for comfort, but hey, you never know:

(Maybe) Hale commented on Not Me                                         Mon, Nov 23, 2015 at 4:39 PM

Perhaps if you gave us your real name this would clear up

More information about Hale

IP: 152.15.161.62

2 – TWIG AS TOM BECKER takes matters into his own hands as he starts at the top posting as Tom Becker. This post gave me a bit of a start as you can well imagine, and then I wondered why (fake) Tom couldn’t spell anonymous.

Tom Becker commented on Not Me                                    Tue, Nov 24, 2015 at 6:41 PM

Who are you? You are doing a lot of damage by remaining annonymous

More information about Tom Becker

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

3 – REAL BIJOU enters the conversation. Note the different IP address below her comment.

Bijou Miller commented on Not Me                                     Wed, Nov 25, 2015 at 9:12 PM

Is that a threat? Who is “us”? It sounds like you guys (“us”) are using this fake fake George to smoke out the real fake George. I agree that the name is irrelevant at this point. You just don’t like that Drift of the Day, makes some very very valid points.

More information about Bijou Miller

IP: 74.64.96.174, nyc.res.rr.com

4 – TWIG AS JOANNE has a few choice words for me.

Joanne Kimmerland commented on Not Me           Wed, Nov 25, 2015 at 10:44 PM

You are a coward hiding behind a pen name. Why do you want Becker fired? No one has any respect for you. Crawl back into your hole and trouble us no more

More information about Joanne Kimmerland

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

5 – TWIG AS MIKE

Mike Sullivan commented on Not Me                      Wed, Nov 25, 2015 at 10:45 PM

Tell us who you are!

More information about Mike Sullivan

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

6 – REAL (Anonymous) PUSS as I start Thanksgiving morning having no idea as to how ridiculous this is going to get in the next 36 hours. Puss comments here asking for transparency and posts on my Amp Redux v. 3.0 Facebook page as Cat Virginia. She also commented once that she’d reveal who she was, if I revealed who I am. I declined. #justalittlehypocrisy

PussVHBWK (@PussVhbwk) commented on Not Me    Thu, Nov 26, 2015 at 8:11 AM

Exactly.
Transparency – operating in the light of day – benefits leaders as much as the community. When you operate behind closed doors and fake identities, anyone can put words in your mouth.

More information about PussVHBWK (@PussVhbwk)

IP: 73.174.1.29, c-73-174-1-29.hsd1.pa.comcast.net

7 – TWIG AS MIKE gets the dirty trick machine cranked up for Black Friday.

Mike Sullivan commented on Not Me          Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:16 PM

You are a coward

More information about Mike Sullivan

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

8 – TWIG AS HALE now starts in on Bijou & Greg in what will be a concerted effort to smoke me out, and threatens to post that Greg is George Seaver.

Hale Oliver commented on Not Me              Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:28 PM

Bijou:

No one is threatening you or anyone. I just think we deserve to know who George T Seaver really is. Yes, “The Drift” makes some valid observations that many disagree with. Some also agree. The point is why is he/she so ashamed of who he/she is? Jane and I proudly sign our names. So did Bill Follansbee and Rick Rieser.

Do you know who the author of Drift of the Day is? Is it you or Greg? I suspect this may in fact be the case and may add my suspicions to my next post. If you and Greg are not George T Seaver, please let me know directly at haleoliverchq@gmail.com and I will not post my theory. If you know George please urge him to come forth and be honest with all of us.

More information about Hale Oliver

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

9 – TWIG AS HALE again as he rudely zeroes in on Greg and seems to have forgotten that he just posted as Hale two minutes earlier. Unless of course, if fake Hale is responding to anonymous Puss, then it all makes sense…if I didn’t laugh, I might cry.

Hale Oliver commented on Not Me              Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:30 PM

I agree entirely. This George T Seaver fellow needs to reveal his/her real name. My sources point toward Greg Miller, but I may be wrong

More information about Hale Oliver

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

10 – TWIG AS HALE wants me to man up. Somehow, I can’t see Hale saying it that way.

Hale Oliver commented on Not Me             Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:30 PM

Once again, please consider manning up and revealing your real name.

More information about Hale Oliver

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

11 – TWIG AS JOANNE devolves to name calling and his spelling issues continue.

Joanne Kimmerland commented on Not Me           Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:36 PM

You are a sad pathetic little creature, hiding under a rock like the salamanders in the south ravine.

You and your olk are the problem.

More information about Joanne Kimmerland

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

12 – TWIG AS HERMAN once again brings my Grandma into it. He did this in the CHQ News and his first fake email. And he accuses me of doing damage to CHQ…priceless!

Herman Melt commented on Not Me                       Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:40 PM

Why are you hiding? Your Chautauqua grandmother would be very ashamed of your behavior, though she would still love you. As we say in the town “grow a pair.” Really you are doing enormous damage to Tom Becker and this administration

More information about Herman Melt

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

13 – TWIG AS DON is the rumor of Greg.

Don Greenhouse commented on Not Me                Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:41 PM

Just heard a rumor that Greg is George T Seaver. Is this true? I mostly agree with what Greg writes.

Don

More information about Don Greenhouse

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

14 – TWIG AS HUGH continues on Bijou & Greg. Maybe it’s just me, but in my humble opinion, Hugh would certainly deal with this privately instead of airing it out on my site for all to see. Twig is just making this stuff up on the fly.

Hugh Butler commented on Not Me                        Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 12:47 PM

Good Morning Bijou,

The word at the library is that Greg is the real George T Seaver. If so he should consider sending a letter to the trustees letting us know he is the author. This will put an end to the fake George T Seaver problem.

Happy Thanksgiving,
Hugh

More information about Hugh Butler

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

15 – REAL BIJOU setting the record straight.

Bijou Miller commented on Not Me                         Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 2:03 PM

Hugh, I am not George Seaver. Greg is not George Seaver. By the way, did you happen to see the Facebook page attributed to George Seaver that posted the “Chautauqua Renewal” drivel? You appear to be George’s cousin. Not a joke.

More information about Bijou Miller

IP: 74.64.96.174, cpe-74-64-96-174.nyc.res.rr.com

16 – TWIG AS HUGH again is tilting at windmills.

Hugh Butler commented on Not Me                        Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 4:56 PM

Well if it is not Greg then who is the original George T Seaver? Do you know who it is? could Greg be doing this without your knowledge?

More information about Hugh Butler

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

17 – TWIG AS ROBERT and a little more bad spelling as I’m sensing a common theme.

Robert Harris commented on Not Me          Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:00 PM

You’re an able writer, though not very interesting to me, given your prejorative tone and patronizing perspective. Why are you afraid to come forward and identify yourself?

More information about Robert Harris

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

18 – TWIG AS CAROL and some sympathy for me.

Carol Chimento commented on Not Me      Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:01 PM

During this time of Thanksgiving, I am both shocked and dismayed that you once again ask for the resignation of Tom Becker. I do not know who you are and no one I have talked to knows either, which leads me to believe you are hiding behind a pseudonym. I do not know your motivation, but can only conclude that you are a very angry and unhappy person. You have my sympathy.

More information about Carol Chimento

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

19 – TWIG AS JOE TWIST and Joe confirmed that he didn’t post this via email to me. And Twig’s calling me reprehensible…Wow!

Joe Twist commented on Not Me                Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:03 PM

I just started reading this……you have no right to call these people dimwits…that disagree passionately……just because I don’t agree, doesn’t make them dim wits……they have the courage to say who they are….……what you just did is reprehensible to Chautauqua I have heard you are a board member for CPOA – doubly reprehensible

More information about Joe Twist

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

20 – TWIG AS MARK and more bad grammar. Twig is hitting a prodigious posting pace and incredulously asks me what kind of person I am. Truth is stranger than fiction.

Mark Maxwell commented on Not Me                      Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:05 PM

dimwits ? One word tells us all we need to know about the those who would use their wealth and clout and arrogance to vandalize Chautauqua’s crown jewel of architecture. Just what kind of person are you?

More information about Mark Maxwell

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

21 – TWIG AS TIM with some attitude, and again brings up Greg & the Board.

Timothy McEnrey commented on Not Me               Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:07 PM

Your pompous attitude is only matched by your lack of intelligence and moribund soul. Moving Chautauqua forward, as you put it, strips the place the place of everything that has made it the irreplaceable institution that it has been over the last 120 years and hopefully will be for the next 120 years. Maybe you should consider spending your holidays in an all-inclusive resort with all the modern amenities. I hear those places are all about renewal. Someone just told me you are a board member named Miller. Are you related to Jeff?

More information about Timothy McEnrey

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

22- TWIG AS _______ with a twist, as this message was sent by the real _______as an email reply to the Fake George email which went back to Twig via chimp mail. Twig copied the message and posted it on my site as ________. I confirmed this with her via email.

THIS COMMENT HAS BEEN DELETED AT THE REQUEST OF THE RELUCTANT PERSON TWIG POSTED AS.

23 – TWIG AS MIKE knocking me for the words he wrote with my fake pen name.

Mike commented on Not Me                                     Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:11 PM

Mr. Seaver,

The easiest way to lose everyone’s attention in a letter is to call the audience “dimwits” and “fools”. I agree with you on Tom Becker but you just alienated the group that would back your calls for new leadership. Way to go, dummy! You have done enormous damage to CI and Tom Becker

Michael L. Aughenbaugh-5th Generation Chautauquan

More information about Mike

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

24 – TWIG AS ALAN BATES keeps banging the drum insulting and judging, trying to smoke me out. And he is most certainly right this time about that veil of anonymity, as we see right through him.

Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:14 PM

Alan Bates commented on Not Me

Thanks George, for again sharing your omniscience. It will come back to bite you. Are you just now discovering the internet? It’s been around for a while and lots of people have found out the hard way, that it does not provide a very strong veil of anonymity. That aside, your musings are not very Chautauqua-like, and in fact, attempt to stunt informed dialogue among folks with differing views. If you had any courage, and anything really meaningful or productive to contribute, you would do it yourself, and not under an alias. Just learned from a board member that you are a CPOA board member. You should be ashamed Cowboy up, or shut up.
Regards
Alan Bates

More information about Alan Bates

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

25 – TWIG AS RICK RIESER thanking me for taking up his cause. If it wasn’t so sad it might be funny.

Rick Rieser commented on Not Me                                     Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:16 PM

George [whoever you are], Surprised that you would take up my call, made last summer, for Tom to step down. I’m on board for all the reasons mentioned, and a few others left unspoken. Happy thanksgiving, Rick Rieser

More information about Rick Rieser

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

26 – TWIG AS HUGH AGAIN continues his assault on Bijou & Greg using Hugh’s name and my site to do it. Absolutely unbelievable!

Hugh Butler commented on Not Me                                    Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:20 PM

Bijou I am getting a lot of phone calls from the other Winter Chautauquans and they are all telling me that Greg Miller is writing as George T Seaver. If this is true he should step forward and take credit. He has a lot of fans on the grounds. If it is not Greg, perhaps it is Jeff. He is a pretty good writer I hear. Enjoy that turkey casserole

Hugh

More information about Hugh Butler

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

27 – TWIG AS ALGERNON using ALL CAPS, which most know, is just plain rude.

Algernon Stmple commented on Not Me                Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:27 PM

YOUR NAME IS WHAT WE ALL DEMAND. PLEASE MAN UP AND IDENTIFY YOURSELF. YOU MIGHT FIND THE TRUTH SETS YOU FREE. WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO FEAR? DO YOU WORK FOR CHAUTAUQUA INSTITUTION? HOW CAN YOU TAKE THEIR MONEY AND THEN DERIDE TOM!

More information about Algernon Stmple

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

28 – TWIG AS BERNICE with bad grammar & spelling. He must be getting tired.

Bernice Flotts commented on Not Me                     Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 5:30 PM

How could your identity get stolen? If so are all these posts bogus? This is whole secret thing is not very Chautauqua of you! Obviously your were nat raised by well mannered people.

Bernice

More information about Bernice Flotts

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

For those of you keeping score at home, Twig convulsively posts 13 Comments in 34 minutes on my site as he spent Black Friday being a very busy boy playing dirty tricks. In need of sustenance and a cold beverage he takes a 2 ½ hour break.

29 – FAKE JAMES – The following comment by James Dandi (Jim Dandy?) smells of Twigs CHQ News parody handiwork. Unless of course Mr. Dandi is real, then we both owe him an apology.

James Dandi commented on Not Me                       Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 8:10 PM

You just natter on like some sort of silly woman and you have even less sense. WHY DO YOU HATE PRESIDENT BECKER? Please tell us who you are.

James

More information about James Dandi

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

30 – TWIG AS MARY LEE TALBOT and he didn’t get her name right. I also confirmed with Mary Lee via email.

Marylee Talbot commented on Not Me                    Fri, Nov 27, 2015 at 9:43 PM

WHY DO YOU HATE TOM? You are mean spirited

More information about Marylee Talbot

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

31 – REAL AARON as Twigs posting is garnering attention. I confirmed this with Aaron.

Aaron Sorensen commented on Not Me                 Sat, Nov 28, 2015 at 9:26 AM

Wow — all of this controversy regarding the real Seaver versus the fake Seaver and which one is loyal to what one and the terrible mix-up that now no one can understand who are the good guys and who are the bad guys… It reminds me of when I used to read my son The Sneetches (http://www.csun.edu/faculty/sheena.malhotra/GRCS-Files/Final%20Projects/The%20Sneetches.htm ) at bedtime. Where is Dr. Seuss when we need him to write story with a happy ending about the frightening divide in the Chautauqua community?

More information about Aaron Sorensen

IP: 73.54.7.39, c-73-54-7-39.hsd1.fl.comcast.net

32 – REAL PATTI as friends of George come to my defense.

Pati Piper commented on Not Me                Sat, Nov 28, 2015 at 10:40 AM

Dear George,

We immediately realized you had been “hacked” because the style of the email was not like you and was an example of what we call the “Mean Chautauqua”. Perhaps you should consider legal action because what the culprit has done reeks of illegality. We are sorry that you have been attacked and called names because we know that you have defended Chautauqua’s leadership from the start!

Pati Piper

More information about Pati Piper

IP: 70.195.133.174, 174.sub-70-195-133.myvzw.com

33 – REAL NAT weighs in for me.

Sat, Nov 28, 2015 at 5:42 PM

natc commented on Not Me

Dear George,
I know this wasn’t you who posted this about Tom Becker. You have consistently been on the side of amp renewal. Your posts have been educational and never with nasty lies.
I know who did this and I will do all I can to see that his name is synonymous with MUD.

34 – TWIG AS JORGE states his case. But many of the people Twig impersonates posting on my site are REAL people and he has put plenty of real words in their mouths.

Jorge Valdez commented on Not Me                                   Sat, Nov 28, 2015 at 10:35 PM

Sadly, only real people can file lawsuits, and George T Seaver is of course not a real person.

More information about Jorge Valdez

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.net

35 – TWIG AS YET ANOTHER JORGE calls Nat out. Seriously…what is wrong with you?

Jorge Gonzales commented on Not Me                              Thu, Dec 3, 2015 at 5:10 PM

Hey Nat, this is Mudd. I prefer the double D option.

Sounds like you want an evening with the big boys. When and where works for you?

More information about Jorge Gonzales

IP: 99.114.148.53, 99-114-148-53.lightspeed.chrlnc.sbcglobal.ne

That was the majority of the comments and now we continue with Twig’s Trail

4 – Twig Created A Fake George Seaver Facebook Page and Friend Requested People

Creepy GirlWaldos dog

Original Fake Facebook George Pic (L) & Current Pic – Waldo’s Dog (R)

The image above (L) I have refereed to as Creepy Girl which was the first one he used when he set up a fake George Seaver Facebook page. I saw the page and just laughed at it until he started friend requesting people. Just for the record I had to set up my George Seaver pen name page so I could post my Amp Redux v. 3.0 page. I never thought about friend requesting anyone as pen names shouldn’t be doing things like that. Yet Twig is still actively friend requesting as Fake George and Leftcadio Hern – Rogue Writer The Chautauqua News. He friend requested my George as both of them.

Leftcadio HernLeftcadio Hern

5 – Twig Emailed a Board Member as George Seaver Last Spring

Twig  sent an email using my mail chimp email (that he set up for me, and controls) to a Chautauqua Institution Board member, posing as me, asking about the Amp Renewal project. The Board member noticed the different email address and forwarded it to me with a warning to be careful. I immediately sent Twig an email via the Gadfly account. Here are excerpts from my exchange with Twig below:

My email to Twig:

And corresponding shared values. Lets not make any more emails to board members…or anyone else for that matter pretending to be a pretend me.

George

P.S. #outofbounds, #overthetop, #toooooofar

Twigs reply to me:

George

Oh that was part of the hunt for your identity.  Thank you for the clue. Sooo, you are either (the Board member) or you have shared your secrets with him. This narrows the circle quite substantially. The fact that you identified “a board member” also helps a bit. Fortunately, since I am your publisher and benefit by your postings (though readership is down a bit this week) it behooves me to keep your secret.  Oops, need to be more careful in the future…..Sooo, have a grand Sunday afternoon and here is hoping you successfully stay in the closet for a bit longer.

The Gadfly

6 – Goading George (me) Into Posting After Save the Amp or Hale’s Voices sent emails. He clearly enjoys the give and take.

After Brian or Hale would post and/or send emails Twig would email me to let me know, asking if I wanted to reply/rebut. This example below after my first post:

It seems based on the howls that you have drawn a bit of blood from the Amp Huggers. We do hope they have not discouraged you from your quest to bring enlightenment to the multitudes of Chautauqua Institution. Your many new fans would miss you. Standing by for your next release

Team Gadfly

7 – Changing My Post Titles in the Emails He Sends Out For Me To Undermine My Posts.

Now that Twig has exposed himself in his misbegotten quest for new leadership, I understand why he chose this path. Here are a few examples of how he changed my post titles to undermine my messages:

After the initial uproar over my pen name and the corresponding conspiracy theories Twig used the following banner in my email below to him. I sent him this email asking him to change that:

George’s Email to the Gadfly (Twig)

Hey just a quick note to hopefully correct the title.

I didn’t receive it directly but saw the following in a reply sent to me.

Twigs Dod banner for mail chimp CI's DOD
The banner above was at the top of the page and I wanted to make it clear that I am not affiliated w/ the Institution.

As everybody is nitpicking the heck out of everything I just wanted to make that clear.

Thanks again and I remain,   Curiously George

Here’s Twigs Reply using the  Happy Chautauquan Account <chautauquacommunity@gmail.com>:

GTS

The speculation of your relationship to the Colonnade is part of the fun.

We intentionally chose this ambiguous headline. It is certainly true and only a little misleading. Besides your nom-de-plume feeds the conspiracy theorists on both sides of the issue.  Of course since we do not know who you are either, perhaps George Murphy moonlights as George Seaver. Who knows?

If you would like to release your true verifiable identity, we would publish it for you, but we hope you keep the “Waldo” game going a bit longer.

What great fun,

TheGadfly

Debunking Myths & Bad Analogies Part 1 was my post title and the subject line I wanted as I wrote about the structural issues with the Amp.

He made the subject line: Time to DEMOLISH that Old Chautauqua Amp.

I complained with the following email:

From George:

Your subject line antagonizes and misrepresents. Does you manipulation belie your feelings? Report or represent!

G

Gadfly (Twig) reply:

George

Nope, we really do not care if the amphitheater stands or falls. However, We do like juicing the controversial aspect of the Amp for the same reason any newspaper writes a salacious headline … Readers love them. If you keep writing we will keep publishing

TheGadfly

When I posted The Chautauqua of the Future re: the 1979 Season debate on the CSO, he titled it Big Symphony Changes.

8 – The rest of his dirty tricks are less damaging but worth noting.

Waldo found

  • I had asked him early on to provide a link to my Drift of the Day site so people could read the other pages/posts at their convenience. He replied that people only want to read the emails.
  • When he finally put a link in he put it right next to a waving Waldo asking people to tap to sign up for the blog. I wanted it to say “to read this post directly in a separate browser tap here to go to my Drift of the Day home page to read this post and other pages.

Waldo wavingGreetings fans, please tap here to sign up for my Blog

  • When the conspiracy theorists thought I worked for Chautauqua and I posted my About George page he added a dozen Waldo’s in the right hand margin.
  • He managed the emails I was supposed to receive via mail chimp as he had first look at them and only sent me the ones he wanted me to see.